Last week, a young Dutch woman was arrested outside an abortion clinic in Utrecht in the Netherlands. Thirty-five weeks pregnant herself, she had offered leaflets to two people; one took a brochure, the other declined. The police arrived and, without evidence, arrested the woman on fictitious allegations of “disturbing the peace.” It was the ninth recent arrest made for peacefully engaging in pro-life outreach outside an abortion facility, even though it is not against the law to do so.
It is the third arrest for the young woman—who chose to remain unidentified—and at times she has been held in jail for three to six hours. Two other Dutch women have been similarly arrested three times each. Dirkje de Ruiter, for example, was arrested last year outside a clinic in Utrecht before she had even passed out a single leaflet; the police informed her that, despite doing nothing illegal, her mere presence constituted “disorder.”
De Ruiter had been previously arrested in Rotterdam; a couple turned away from the clinic as the officers were confronting her. “When I arrived at the police station, all my things had to be handed in, and I was put in a cell measuring 2 metres by 1.5 metres,” she told me. “Some of my clothes had to come off, and I was given a blanket against the cold. In the cell I thanked God for the life that had been saved… I was not afraid.” Again: De Ruiter had not broken any laws.
The arrests of citizens doing peaceful pro-life outreach in the Netherlands are part of a broader continental crackdown on social conservatives, usually Christian, for expressing their beliefs in public. In Brussels earlier this month, Lois McLatchie of the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) and Chris Elston, the anti-trans ideology activist known to his social media followers as “Billboard Chris,” were arrested, strip-searched, and detained for hours by police merely for holding signs reading “Children Are Never Born In The Wrong Body” and “Children Cannot Consent To Puberty Blockers.” Their signs were destroyed. They were charged with no crime.
In the United Kingdom, pro-lifers have been arrested for the thought crime of silent prayer so frequently that the Trump administration took the extraordinary step in March of sending “a team of U.S. officials to the UK to investigate concerns over freedom of speech restrictions,” according to GB News. Diplomats from the U.S. Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, led by State Department adviser Samuel Samson, met with five British pro-lifers who had been arrested for silent prayer at clinics across the country.
The U.S. diplomats met with Adam Smith-Connor, the veteran (famously referenced by Vice President J.D. Vance in his Munich Conference Speech in February) arrested for praying about his own aborted son near a clinic in Bournemouth; Catholic priest Fr. Sean Gough; Isabel Vaughan-Spruce, who was interrogated by officers and arrested when she said that she “might be praying in her head;” Livia Tossici-Bolt, arrested for silently holding a sign reading “Here to talk, if you want”; and Rose Docherty, the 74-year-old grandmother arrested outside Glasgow’s Queen Elizabeth University Hospital.
J.D. Vance was criticized, including by UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, for his condemnation of Europe’s crackdown on dissent; Scottish MSP Gillian Mackay, the parliamentarian responsible for Scotland’s draconian “buffer zone” bill, insisted that Vance’s allegation that people could be arrested for praying in their own homes if they fell within the buffer zone was “absolute nonsense.” In an interview with the BBC, Mackay was forced to admit that her bill could, in fact, be applied in precisely the way that Vance described if someone was praying near their window and someone happened to see them.
The contrast between the state’s treatment of social conservatives and the free rein given to their ideological opponents is stark. Earlier this month, Dutch activist Kees van Helden told me a “group of [pro-life] protesters was threatened. Materials were destroyed with a karate shovel. Three reports were filed that morning and the police did not come.” When he called the police, it turned out someone had deleted the reports. Abortion activists threaten peaceful pro-life events across the continent, frequently engaging in actual violence and harassment, but are rarely disturbed by police.
Europe’s social conservatives frequently find themselves between the pincers of state crackdowns and street-level opposition—especially those who oppose the transgender agenda, who face violence from trans activists and investigation and prosecution for recently-invented crimes such as “misgendering” (Norway) or “transphobia” (Greece). Even though charges are often not pursued, the process is the punishment. By arresting a heavily pregnant woman for handing out pamphlets and offering help to other pregnant women, the state dramatically raises the price of peaceful pro-life speech and sends a clear message to others. That, of course, is the point.
A Washington source connected to the Trump Administration recently told the UK Independent that U.S. Vice President JD Vance has become “obsessed by the fall of Western civilization” in general and the collapse of free speech in Europe specifically. It is about time somebody is.
Europe’s Woke Police State Is Targeting Social Conservatives
Scott Olson / Getty Images via AFP
You may also like
Europe’s Patriots Uniting
The European Right is joining forces in rejecting the abolition of unanimous decision-making in the EU and opposing the use of the rule of law as a political tool, while standing up for energy sovereignty and taking a firm position against mass migration.
Finnish Supreme Court Convicts Päivi Räsänen of “Hate Speech”
The MP was found “criminally liable” for a 22-year-old pamphlet stating the biblical views on homosexuality.
Not Paranoid Enough: Security and the Thiel Lectures in Rome
Leaking the precise location of a high-security private event to a press corps with an appetite for the darkest possible framing, in a city where networks were actively building nail bombs, was reckless.
Last week, a young Dutch woman was arrested outside an abortion clinic in Utrecht in the Netherlands. Thirty-five weeks pregnant herself, she had offered leaflets to two people; one took a brochure, the other declined. The police arrived and, without evidence, arrested the woman on fictitious allegations of “disturbing the peace.” It was the ninth recent arrest made for peacefully engaging in pro-life outreach outside an abortion facility, even though it is not against the law to do so.
It is the third arrest for the young woman—who chose to remain unidentified—and at times she has been held in jail for three to six hours. Two other Dutch women have been similarly arrested three times each. Dirkje de Ruiter, for example, was arrested last year outside a clinic in Utrecht before she had even passed out a single leaflet; the police informed her that, despite doing nothing illegal, her mere presence constituted “disorder.”
De Ruiter had been previously arrested in Rotterdam; a couple turned away from the clinic as the officers were confronting her. “When I arrived at the police station, all my things had to be handed in, and I was put in a cell measuring 2 metres by 1.5 metres,” she told me. “Some of my clothes had to come off, and I was given a blanket against the cold. In the cell I thanked God for the life that had been saved… I was not afraid.” Again: De Ruiter had not broken any laws.
The arrests of citizens doing peaceful pro-life outreach in the Netherlands are part of a broader continental crackdown on social conservatives, usually Christian, for expressing their beliefs in public. In Brussels earlier this month, Lois McLatchie of the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) and Chris Elston, the anti-trans ideology activist known to his social media followers as “Billboard Chris,” were arrested, strip-searched, and detained for hours by police merely for holding signs reading “Children Are Never Born In The Wrong Body” and “Children Cannot Consent To Puberty Blockers.” Their signs were destroyed. They were charged with no crime.
In the United Kingdom, pro-lifers have been arrested for the thought crime of silent prayer so frequently that the Trump administration took the extraordinary step in March of sending “a team of U.S. officials to the UK to investigate concerns over freedom of speech restrictions,” according to GB News. Diplomats from the U.S. Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, led by State Department adviser Samuel Samson, met with five British pro-lifers who had been arrested for silent prayer at clinics across the country.
The U.S. diplomats met with Adam Smith-Connor, the veteran (famously referenced by Vice President J.D. Vance in his Munich Conference Speech in February) arrested for praying about his own aborted son near a clinic in Bournemouth; Catholic priest Fr. Sean Gough; Isabel Vaughan-Spruce, who was interrogated by officers and arrested when she said that she “might be praying in her head;” Livia Tossici-Bolt, arrested for silently holding a sign reading “Here to talk, if you want”; and Rose Docherty, the 74-year-old grandmother arrested outside Glasgow’s Queen Elizabeth University Hospital.
J.D. Vance was criticized, including by UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, for his condemnation of Europe’s crackdown on dissent; Scottish MSP Gillian Mackay, the parliamentarian responsible for Scotland’s draconian “buffer zone” bill, insisted that Vance’s allegation that people could be arrested for praying in their own homes if they fell within the buffer zone was “absolute nonsense.” In an interview with the BBC, Mackay was forced to admit that her bill could, in fact, be applied in precisely the way that Vance described if someone was praying near their window and someone happened to see them.
The contrast between the state’s treatment of social conservatives and the free rein given to their ideological opponents is stark. Earlier this month, Dutch activist Kees van Helden told me a “group of [pro-life] protesters was threatened. Materials were destroyed with a karate shovel. Three reports were filed that morning and the police did not come.” When he called the police, it turned out someone had deleted the reports. Abortion activists threaten peaceful pro-life events across the continent, frequently engaging in actual violence and harassment, but are rarely disturbed by police.
Europe’s social conservatives frequently find themselves between the pincers of state crackdowns and street-level opposition—especially those who oppose the transgender agenda, who face violence from trans activists and investigation and prosecution for recently-invented crimes such as “misgendering” (Norway) or “transphobia” (Greece). Even though charges are often not pursued, the process is the punishment. By arresting a heavily pregnant woman for handing out pamphlets and offering help to other pregnant women, the state dramatically raises the price of peaceful pro-life speech and sends a clear message to others. That, of course, is the point.
A Washington source connected to the Trump Administration recently told the UK Independent that U.S. Vice President JD Vance has become “obsessed by the fall of Western civilization” in general and the collapse of free speech in Europe specifically. It is about time somebody is.
Our community starts with you
READ NEXT
Discovering Chartreuse Elixir: A Very Spiritual Spirit
First Mover, Last Forgiven: What the Cato Institute Gets Wrong on Hungary
The Tradition of the Cristo de Mena